Unified Multi-Caller Ensemble (UME) Generates an Unbiased Maize Haplotype Map for Variable Coverage Whole Genome Data.

We present a novel diversity-focused haplotype map (HapMap) that characterizes over 64.5 million maize (Zea mays ssp. mays) single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) genotyped across 818 individuals from diverse backgrounds. This HapMap aims to balance the variation obtained from domesticated landraces and inbred lines, outgroup Zea spp. and more distant Tripsacum spp. in order to minimize ascertainment bias for diversity studies. Included individuals derive from public data from various experimental setups and coverages, which is challenging for standard SNP callers to accommodate. We provide evidence of coverage biases associated with standard callers that influence resulting variation and introduce a novel approach called Unified Multi-Caller Ensemble (UME), which enhances variant calling accuracy in low-coverage and mixed-coverage genomic datasets. UME corrects for coverage bias resulting from inter-sample coverage heterogeneity by leveraging evidence from variant callers with orthogonal strategies, re-calibrating the error probabilities across callers to minimize the impact of error biases inherent to a given caller. It outperforms individual strategies and excels in de novo variant calling, taking advantage of instances of higher depth reads, even in low coverage individuals, while preserving biologically informative variant relationships across coverage levels. An important feature of UME is the independence from population allele frequencies in the discovery panel, thus avoiding ascertainment bias resulting from unbalanced input genetic diversity. Discovered variants are less affected by ascertainment bias because no population filtering is used, and the full diversity of SNPs is retained in the final variant call set to maximize the utility of the dataset for production calling newly sequenced samples. We present a strategy for filtering the recalibrated error profiles that relies on maximizing demographic signals to retain genetic relationships within the population while reducing sequencing error. After the variant discovery phase, we employ the UME production stage, which enriches genotype calling across all coverage levels, benefiting low-coverage samples. Error introduced in this process is removed through subsequent filtering. Using this approach, we generated a coverage bias-controlled maize HapMap database, providing a comprehensive representation of maize accessions and emphasizing landrace diversity. This diverse panel of domesticated maize and outgroups from across the Americas enables accurate genotyping in low-coverage samples while offering crucial context for interpreting diversity, particularly for natural diversity and paleogenomic analyses.