Benchmark Study for Calculations of pKa Values of Metal Ligands in Proteins.

We have compared the performance of 64 different computational methods, based on combined quantum mechanical (QM) and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) or QM-cluster calculations in a continuum solvent, to estimate the acid constant (pKa) of metal-bound ligands in proteins. As a calibration set, we use 12 experimental pKa values from six different proteins that involve Zn2+, Fe3+, or Fe4+. We employ two different density functional theory (DFT) methods (TPSS and B3LYP), two basis sets (def2-SV(P) and def2-TZVPD), QM regions of three different sizes (∼40, ∼100, and ∼350 atoms), relaxed or fixed surroundings, and three different values of the dielectric constant of the continuum-solvation model (ε = 4, 20, or 80). The results clearly show that QM-cluster+continuum-solvation is much better than QM/MM. In general, the most accurate results are obtained with ε = 80 and the minimal QM region. The two DFT methods, the two basis sets, and relaxing or fixing the surroundings give similar results. The best-performing method is TPSS with the minimal QM region, def2-TZVPD, relaxed surroundings, and ε = 80, yielding a mean absolute deviation (after removal of a systematic error of 11.6 pKa units, pu) of 2.0 pu and a maximum deviation of 5.0 pu. The coefficient of determination (R2) and Kendall's τ with respect to the experimental pKa values are both 0.64, while Spearman's rank correlation coefficient is 0.78. This level of accuracy should be sufficient to reliably determine the protonation states of metal-bound ligands in QM-based studies of enzymatic reaction mechanisms.