Phylotranscriptomics and genome-size evidence clarify the Taiwanese Cirsium japonicum complex and delimit C. brevicaule and allied East Asian thistles.

backgroundRapid diversification in island floras often creates taxonomic uncertainty, particularly for morphologically variable plant complexes. The Cirsium japonicum complex, a widespread and medicinally important group in East Asia, exemplifies this challenge, with unclear species boundaries and conflicting varietal definitions. This is especially true in Taiwan, where multiple endemic forms co-occur. Despite its ecological and pharmacological significance, due to morphological overlap, fragmented distributions, and the absence of comprehensive phylogenomic analysis, the evolutionary relationships and lineage delimitations within this complex remain unresolved. In this study, we analyzed phylotranscriptomic data from 37 thistle accessions comprising the C. japonicum complex and the allied C. brevicaule group, constructed multigene coalescent species trees, and integrated morphometrics, genome size mapping, demographic history, and distribution modeling.

resultsThree monophyletic subsections (Sinocirsium, Arenicola, and Nipponocirsium; all within Cirsium sect. Onotrophe) diverged 1.30–1.02 million years ago (Mya) (95% highest posterior density (HPD): 1.62–0.71 Mya) during early Quaternary glaciations. Within subsect. Sinocirsium, five lineages emerged: Japanese var. japonicum and four Taiwanese varieties that form two sister pairs (var. albescens vs. var. takaoense and var. australe vs. var. fukienense). In subsect. Arenicola, two distinct species endemic to the Ryukyu Islands, C. brevicaule and C. irumtiense, exist across the Miyako Strait. The ancestral genome size was estimated at ~1.3 pg and underwent several independent reductions (e.g., var. takaoense, 1.01 pg) and expansions (e.g., C. brevicaule, 1.93 pg) without chromosomal changes. Skyline plots indicate a late Pleistocene bottleneck and Holocene rebound in var. takaoense, whereas var. fukienense remained stable, matching historical habitat suitability.

conclusionsWe combined phylotranscriptomic trees, genome-size trajectories, and demographic models to resolve East Asian Cirsium into two Ryukyu species (C. brevicaule, C. irumtiense) and a five-lineage C. japonicum complex spanning Taiwan to Japan. Revised diagnoses confirm that true C. brevicaule is confined to the central Ryukyus, while Taiwanese records reflect the complex, including var. takaoense, australe, fukienense, and the Hengchun endemic var. albescens, which meets IUCN vulnerability criteria due to restricted range and medicinal harvest. We further clarify the placement of C. morii, link floral-color polymorphism in var. takaoense to anthocyanin expression and pollinator preference, and show that Quaternary glaciations, island fragmentation, and 2C shifts shaped diversification, whereas late Pleistocene bottlenecks and Holocene expansions structured populations. Together, this synthesis refines taxonomy, informs conservation, and supports sustainable use.