Understanding the Competition between Alcohol Formation and Dimerization during Electrochemical Reduction of Aromatic Carbonyl Compounds.

The electrochemical reductive dimerization of small aromatic carbonyl compounds derived from lignocellulosic biomass is a crucial C-C coupling reaction for upgrading small molecules to long-chain hydrocarbons, particularly in the synthesis of drop-in sustainable aviation fuels. Although other electrochemical reduction reactions of these reactants (i.e., hydrogenation and hydrogenolysis) have undergone extensive mechanistic investigation, the understanding of dimerization remains relatively underdeveloped. Most importantly, there is a lack of understanding of the selectivity-determining step between dimerization and monomer reduction and critical factors that can affect this step. In this study, we provide a comprehensive mechanistic model to explain the competition between dimerization and monomer reduction of benzaldehyde under various conditions. Our model proposes that the selectivity between dimerization and monomer reduction depends on the competition between desorption of a ketyl radical from the electrode, necessary for dimerization, and further reduction of the ketyl radical to an alcohol on the electrode by proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET). Computationally comparing the adsorption/desorption energy and PCET activation barrier energy is challenging because conventional DFT calculations substantially underestimate the PCET kinetic barriers. In this study, we employed constrained DFT-based configuration interaction (CDFT-CI) to obtain a reliable comparison of these energies. Our mechanistic model was tested and supported by experimental results obtained with four electrodes (Cu, Pb, Bi, graphite), three pH conditions (acidic, neutral, basic), and three potentials. Our study offers a coherent mechanistic foundation that can explain how each of these conditions impacts the desorption and PCET processes and the selectivities for dimerization and alcohol production.