Cross-Platform Availability of Smartphone Sensors for Depression Indication Systems: Mixed-Methods Umbrella Review.

backgroundA popular trend in depression forecasting research is the development of machine learning models trained with various types of smartphone sensor data and periodic self-ratings to derive early indications of changes in depression severity. While most works focus on model performance, there is little concern about the universal usability and reliable operation of such systems across smartphone platforms. This review serves as foundational work for the MENTINA clinical trial, which investigates smartphone-based health self-management for depression. The usability and reliability of mobile apps for depression are commonly perceived through the lens of the approaches and interventions offered rather than the reliability of the built-in mobile phone functions to support effortless and exact delivery of intended interventions.

objectiveThis work aimed to synthesize existing systematic reviews to identify smartphone sensor modalities used in mental health monitoring and, building on this foundation, assess the cross-platform availability of these data streams using PhoneDB to inform the design and implementation of digital depression indication systems.

methodsTo identify the already used hardware and software sensors and their purposes in mental health monitoring, an umbrella review was conducted. Three electronic databases, including PubMed, Web of Science Core Collection, and Scopus, were searched using smartphone, sensor data, and depression keyword combination to retrieve relevant literature reviews published within the last 5 years (2019-2024). Once the initial search was completed, the extracted hardware sensors were checked for availability on Android and iOS smartphones by analyzing device specifications in PhoneDB over the last 10 years.

resultsThe extracted data streams observed across the 9 included studies covered 16 hardware and 3 software data streams. Hardware data streams included accelerometers, barometers, battery levels, Bluetooth, cameras, cellular networks, GPSs, gyroscopes, humidity, light sensors, magnetometers, proximity sensors, sound sensors, step counters, temperature sensors, and Wi-Fi. Software data streams included app usage, call and message logs, and screen status. Hardware component availability on Android and iOS systems showed the changes in component trends from 2014 to 2024 as of September 2024, with the accelerometers, batteries, cameras, and GPSs remaining consistent on Android and iOS, while components such as gyroscopes, step counters, and barometers gradually increased over the years, particularly on Android.

conclusionsMultiple data streams identified in the literature review showed a consistent increase in availability over time, enabling improved use of these outputs for depression forecasting and the training of machine learning models with diverse smartphone data, including sensor-derived information. For more precise and reliable data to be used in the mental health field, particularly in critical areas such as tracking and predicting changes in depression severity, further research is required to streamline smartphone data across varying mobile hardware and software configurations to provide reliable output for digital mental health purposes.