Extracting epilepsy-related information from unstructured clinic letters using large language models.

objectiveThe emergence of large language models (LLMs) and the increasing prevalence of electronic health records (EHRs) present significant opportunities for advancing health care research and practice. However, research that compares and applies LLMs to extract key epilepsy-related information from unstructured medical free text is under-explored. This study fills this gap by comparing and applying different open-source LLMs and methods to extract epilepsy information from unstructured clinic letters, thereby optimizing EHRs as a resource for the benefit of epilepsy research. We also highlight some limitations of LLMs.

methodsEmploying a dataset of 280 annotated clinic letters from King's College Hospital, we explored the efficacy of open-source LLMs (Llama and Mistral series) for extracting key epilepsy-related information, including epilepsy type, seizure type, current anti-seizure medications (ASMs), and associated symptoms. The study used various extraction methods, including direct extraction, summarized extraction, and contextualized extraction, complemented by role-prompting and few-shot prompting techniques. Performance was evaluated against a gold standard dataset, and was also compared to advanced fine-tuned models and human annotations.

resultsLlama 2 13b (a 13-billion-parameter LLM developed by Meta) demonstrated superior extraction capabilities across tasks by consistently outperforming other LLMs (F1 = .80 in epilepsy-type extraction, F1 = .76 in seizure-type extraction, and F1 = .90 in current ASMs extraction). Here, F1 score is a balanced metric indicating the model's accuracy in correctly identifying relevant information without excessive false positives. The study highlights the direct extraction showing consistent high performance. Comparative analysis showed that LLMs outperformed current approaches like MedCAT (Medical Concept Annotation Tool) in extracting epilepsy-related information (.2 higher in F1). SIGNIFICANCE: The results affirm the potential of LLMs in medical information extraction relating to epilepsy, offering insights into leveraging these models for detailed and accurate data extraction from unstructured texts. The study underscores the importance of method selection in optimizing extraction performance and suggests a promising avenue for enhancing medical research and patient care through advanced natural language processing technologies.