Microbiome metabolic capacity is buffered against phylotype losses by functional redundancy.

Many animals contain a species-rich and diverse gut microbiota that likely contributes to several host-supportive services that include diet processing and nutrient provisioning. Loss of microbiome taxa and their associated metabolic functions as result of perturbations may result in loss of microbiome-level services and reduction of metabolic capacity. If metabolic functions are shared by multiple taxa (i.e., functional redundancy), including deeply divergent lineages, then the impact of taxon/function losses may be dampened. We examined to what degree alterations in phylotype diversity impact microbiome-level metabolic capacity. Feeding two nutritionally imbalanced diets to omnivorous IMPORTANCE: Diet can affect gut microbiome taxonomic composition and diversity, but its impacts on community-level functional capabilities are less clear. Host health and fitness are increasingly being linked to microbiome composition and further modeling of the relationship between microbiome taxonomic and metabolic functional capability is needed to inform these linkages. Invertebrate animal models like the omnivorous American cockroach are ideal for this inquiry because they are amenable to various diets and provide high replicates per treatment at low costs and thus enabling rigorous statistical analyses and hypothesis testing. Microbiome taxonomic composition is diet-labile and diversity was reduced after feeding on unbalanced diets (i.e., post-treatment), but the predicted functional capacities of the post-treatment microbiomes were less affected likely due to the resilience of several abundant taxa surviving the perturbation as well as many metabolic functions being shared by several taxa. These results suggest that both taxonomic and functional profiles should be considered when attempting to infer how perturbations are altering gut microbiome services and possible host outcomes.