Dispersal shapes compositional and functional diversity in aquatic microbial communities.

Segregation and mixing shape the structure and functioning of aquatic microbial communities, but their respective roles are challenging to disentangle in field studies. We explored the hypothesis that functional differences and beta diversity among stochastically assembled communities would increase in the absence of dispersal. Contrariwise, we expected biotic selection during homogenizing dispersal to reduce beta and gamma diversity as well as functional variability. This was experimentally addressed by examining the compositional and functional changes of 20 freshwater bacterial assemblages maintained at identical conditions over seven growth cycles for 34 days and subjected to two consecutive dispersal regimes. Initial dispersal limitation generated high beta diversity and led to the repeated emergence of community types that were dominated by particular taxa. Compositional stability and evenness of the community types varied over successive growth cycles, reflecting differences in functional properties. Carbon use efficiency increased during cultivation, with some communities of unique composition outperforming the replicate community types. Homogenizing dispersal led to high compositional similarity and reduced gamma diversity. While a neutral and a competition-based (Elo-rating) model together largely explained community assembly, a pseudomonad disproportionally dominated across communities, possibly due to interaction-related genomic traits. In conclusion, microbial assemblages stochastically generated by dispersal limitation can be gradually "refined" into distinct community types by subsequent deterministic processes. Segregation of communities represented an insurance mechanism for highly productive but competitively weak microbial taxa that were excluded during community coalescence. IMPORTANCE: We experimentally assessed the compositional and functional responses of freshwater bacterial assemblages exposed to two consecutive dispersal-related events (dispersal limitation and homogenizing dispersal) under identical growth conditions. While segregation led to a decreased local diversity, high beta diversity sustained regional diversity and functional variability. In contrast, homogenizing dispersal reduced the species pool and functional variability of the metacommunity. Our findings highlight the role of dispersal in regulating both diversity and functional variability of aquatic microbial metacommunities, thereby providing crucial insight to predict changes in ecosystem functioning.