Diagnosis of botulism in mammals aided by toxin ELISA and C and D gene RT-PCRs with an emphasis on farm animals.

Animal welfare and ethical considerations limit the use of the mouse lethality bioassay for the detection of botulinum toxins. This study assessed an ELISA and RT-PCRs to detect toxin types C and D in samples from mammals with flaccid paralysis or weakness. DNA/RNA tightly bound to the toxin molecules were used as surrogates for the presence of toxin. In total 391 diverse samples from 101 clinical cases from cattle and 9 other species were examined. Botulism was confirmed by ELISA in samples from 16 cases. Toxin type C or D was identified by RT-PCR in 10 cases, five of which were among the cases confirmed by ELISA. Among the 80 cases with negative samples, sampling was not comprehensive enough in 66 cases (botulism therefore not excluded) but was adequate in 14 cases (no indication of botulism). The last two categories included 16 cases with other laboratory findings explaining the clinical signs. The ELISA that detects botulinum C and D toxins was superior in identifying cases with positive samples compared to the RT-PCRs but the latter were able to identify the toxin type present when positive. Furthermore, the RT-PCRs are available to any laboratory with molecular testing capability. Both laboratory assays can screen a comprehensive range and a large number of samples which is crucial for a successful diagnosis of botulism.