Free hemi-hamate arthroplasty: A review of donor site outcomes.

Introduction: The use of the dorsal hamate as a free osteochondral bone graft or vascularized bone flap has become the mainstay for large, comminuted middle phalanx volar lip fractures. To date, few studies have been conducted in the assessment of donor site morbidity for the hemi-hamate graft or flap, and none have discussed modes of repair or reconstruction of this donor site. Methods: A retrospective analysis of 14 hemi-hamate arthroplasty (HHA) procedures, including 6 vascularized and 8 non-vascularized grafts, from two surgeons was performed. Four hamate defect reconstruction techniques were utilized: no formal reconstruction, autologous bone grafting, gel foam, or synthetic bone substitute. The dorsal capsule was repaired with either extensor retinaculum grafting or by direct closure. Wrist range of motion, pain scores, and radiographic alignment were assessed. Results: At 6 months follow-up, all patients achieved full, pain-free wrist motion compared to the uninjured side, with visual analog scale pain scores of 0. Serial radiographs showed maintained carpal alignment without instability or subluxation. No differences based on the hamate defect reconstruction method or capsular repair technique was demonstrated. Conclusion: Safe return to pain free, unrestricted wrist function is achievable after HHA, regardless of hamate donor site management. Adequate dorsal capsular repair appears critical to prevent instability. Further study is needed to compare techniques, but choice may be guided by surgeon preference in the absence of clear evidence.