Health systems' capacity in availability of human resource for health towards implementation of Universal Health Coverage in Kenya.

introductionKenya faces significant challenges related to health worker shortages, low retention rates, and the equitable distribution of Human Resource for Health (HRH). The Ministry of Health (MOH) in Kenya has established HRH norms and standards that define the minimum requirements for healthcare providers and infrastructure at various levels of the health system. The study assessed on the progress of Universal Health Coverage (UHC) piloting on Human Resource for Health in the country.

methodsThe study utilized a Convergent-Parallel-Mixed-Methods design, incorporating both quantitative and qualitative approaches. The study sampled diverse population groups and randomly selected health facilities. Four UHC pilot counties are paired with two non-UHC pilot counties, one neighboring county and the second county with a geographically distant and does not share a border with any UHC pilot counties. Stratification based on ownership and level was performed, and the required number of facilities per stratum was determined using the square root allocation method. Data on the availability of human resources for health was collected using a customized Kenya Service Availability and Readiness Assessment Mapping (SARAM) tool facilitated by KoBo ToolKitTM open-source software. Data quality checks and validation were conducted, and the HRH general service availability index was measured on availability of Nurses, Clinician, Nutritionist, Laboratory technologist and Pharmacist which is a minimum requirement across all levels of health facilities. Statistical analyses were performed using IBM SPSS version 27 and comparisons between UHC pilot counties and non-UHC counties where significance threshold was established at p < 0.05. Qualitative data collected using focus group discussions and in-depth interview guides. Ethical approval and research permits were obtained, and written informed consent was obtained from all participants.

resultsThe study assessed 746 health facilities with a response rate of 94.3%. Public health facilities accounted for 75% of the sample. The overall healthcare professional availability index score was 17.2%. There was no significant difference in health workers' availability between UHC pilot counties and non-UHC pilot counties at P = 0.834. Public health facilities had a lower index score of 14.7% compared to non-public facilities at 27.0%. Rural areas had the highest staffing shortages, with only 11.1% meeting staffing norms, compared to 31.8% in urban areas and 30.4% in peri-urban areas. Availability of health workers increased with the advancement of The Kenya Essential Package for Health (KEPH Level), with all Level 2 facilities across counties failing to meet MOH staffing norms (0.0%) except Taita Taveta at 8.3%. Among specific cadres, nursing had the highest availability index at 93.2%, followed by clinical officers at 52.3% and laboratory professionals at 55.2%. The least available professions were nutritionists at 21.6% and pharmacist personnel at 33.0%. This result is corroborated by qualitative verbatim.

conclusionThe study findings highlight crucial challenges in healthcare professional availability and distribution in Kenya. The UHC pilot program has not effectively enhanced healthcare facilities to meet the standards for staffing, calling for additional interventions. Rural areas face a pronounced shortage of healthcare workers, necessitating efforts to attract and retain professionals in these regions. Public facilities have lower availability compared to private facilities, raising concerns about accessibility and quality of care provided. Primary healthcare facilities have lower availability than secondary facilities, emphasizing the need to address shortages at the community level. Disparities in the availability of different healthcare cadres must be addressed to meet diverse healthcare needs. Overall, comprehensive interventions are urgently needed to improve access to quality healthcare services and address workforce challenges.