Surgical Resection of Benign Nodules in Lung Cancer Screening: Incidence and Features.

Introduction: Interventions and surgical procedures are common for nonmalignant lung lesions detected on lung cancer screening (LCS). Inadvertent surgical resection of benign nodules with a clinical suspicion of lung cancer can occur, can be associated with complications, and adds to the cost of screening. The objective of this study is to assess the characteristics of surgically resected benign nodules detected on LCS computed tomography which were presumed to be lung cancers. Methods: This retrospective study included 4798 patients who underwent LCS between June 2014 and January 2021. The benign lung nodules, surgically resected with a presumed cancer diagnosis, were identified from the LCS registry. Patient demographics, imaging characteristics, and pathologic diagnoses of benign nodules were analyzed. Results: Of the 4798 patients who underwent LCS, 148 (3.1%) underwent surgical resection of a lung nodule, and of those who had a resection, 19 of 148 (12.8%) had a benign diagnosis (median age = 64 y, range: 56-77 y; F = 12 of 19, 63.2%; M = seven of 19, 36.8%). The median nodule size was 10 mm (range: 6-31 mm). Most nodules were solid (15 of 19, 78.9%), located in the upper lobes (11 of 19; 57.9%), and were peripheral (17 of 19, 89.5%). Most nodules (13 of 17; 76.5%) had interval growth, and four of 17 (23.5%) had increased fluorodeoxyglucose uptake. Of the 19 patients, 17 (89.5%) underwent sublobar resection (16 wedge resection and one segmentectomy), whereas two central nodules (10.5%) had lobectomies. Pathologies identified included focal areas of fibrosis or scarring (n = 8), necrotizing granulomatous inflammation (n = 3), other nonspecific inflammatory focus (n = 3), benign tumors (n = 3), reactive lymphoid hyperplasia (n = 1), and organizing pneumonia (n = 1). Conclusions: Surgical resections of benign nodules that were presumed malignant are infrequent and may be unavoidable given overlapping imaging features of benign and malignant nodules. Knowledge of benign pathologies that can mimic malignancy may help reduce the incidence of unnecessary surgeries.