A Comparative Analysis of Complication Rates in Arthroscopic Repair of the Lateral Ankle Ligament and the Brostrom-Gould Technique: A Systematic Review.

Injury to the lateral ligament is the most common cause of chronic lateral ankle instability. Lateral ankle instability is usually managed through conservative management, but surgery is indicated if this fails to relieve the symptoms. Surgical repair of the lateral ligament involves many surgical techniques including the arthroscopic repair technique and the modified Brostrom-Gould technique. Due to the minimal research on the complication rates of both techniques, this systematic review aims to establish the complication rates. To obtain articles, a detailed systematic search of MEDLINE, PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library was performed. The articles found using the keywords "arthroscopic," "Brostrom," and "Brostrom-Gould" were reviewed by two independent authors. The authors then selected the articles according to our predetermined eligibility criteria. The articles that met our inclusion were then chosen for data extraction. Specific details obtained from the study included the author's details, the setting of the study, and the complications of the study. The online search yielded 975 articles, but only 44 met our inclusion criteria and were included in the review. The total sample size for the review was 2041 patients, the modified Brostrom technique was performed on 760 patients while on the remaining 1281 patients, arthroscopic repair was performed. On the characteristics of the sample, the age of the samples ranged from eight years to 83 years, while the mean BMI ranged from 21.0 kg/m² to 25.3 kg/m². The various complication rates included superficial peroneal nerve injury (2.3% in arthroscopic Brostrom and 0.65% in the Brostrom-Gould), wound infections (1.3% in arthroscopic Brostrom and 1.8% in the Brostrom-Gould), persistent pain (1.5% in the arthroscopic Brostrom and 1.1% in the Brostrom-Gould), and lastly recurrent instability (0.31% in arthroscopic Brostrom and 3.0% in the Brostrom-Gould). Overall, the complication rates of the arthroscopic repair were 11.00%, while those of the modified Brostrom-Gould were 10.65%. The study demonstrated that although the arthroscopic technique had higher complication rates than the modified Brostrom technique, the difference was insignificant. Therefore, we concluded that surgeons performing the arthroscopic Brostrom technique should have good arthroscopic skills to minimize complications.