Sources of bias and limitations of thrombinography: inner filter effect and substrate depletion at the edge of failure algorithm.

backgroundFluorogenic thrombin generation (TG) is a global hemostasis assay that provides an overall representation of hemostasis potential. However, the accurate detection of thrombin activity in plasma may be affected by artifacts inherent to the assay-associated fluorogenic substrate. The significance of the fluorogenic artifacts or their corrections has not been studied in hemophilia treatment applications.

methodsWe sought to investigate TG in hemophilia plasma samples under typical and worst-case fluorogenic artifact conditions and assess the performance of artifact correction algorithms. Severe hemophilic plasma with or without added Factor VIII (FVIII) was evaluated using commercially available and in-house TG reagents, instruments, and software packages. The inner filter effect (IFE) was induced by spiking elevated amounts of fluorophore 7-amino-4-methylcoumarin (AMC) into plasma prior to the TG experiment. Substrate consumption was modeled by adding decreasing amounts of Z-Gly-Gly-Arg-AMC (ZGGR-AMC) to plasma or performing TG in antithrombin deficient plasma.

resultsAll algorithms corrected the AMC-induced IFE and antithrombin-deficiency induced substrate consumption up to a certain level of either artifact (edge of failure) upon which TG results were not returned or overestimated. TG values in FVIII deficient (FVIII-DP) or supplemented plasma were affected similarly. Normalization of FVIII-DP resulted in a more accurate correction of substrate artifacts than algorithmic methods.

conclusionsCorrection algorithms may be effective in situations of moderate fluorogenic substrate artifacts inherent to highly procoagulant samples, but correction may not be required under typical conditions for hemophilia treatment studies if TG parameters can be normalized to a reference plasma sample.