Robot-assisted versus conventional open kidney transplantation: a propensity matched comparison with median follow-up of 5 years.

backgroundRAKT is a relatively newer approach for kidney transplant and has to be proven against the established approach, OKT. RAKT may be beneficial in obese patients as described in literature. Hence, we compared pre-, intra- and postoperative parameters with one year follow-up of both approaches by propensity matching similar characteristics patients.

methodsData of 28 OKT and 28 RAKT propensity matched patients was collected during 2014 to 2022 through the institutional transplant registry. OKT and RAKT patients were propensity matched for confounding factors like donor age, eGFR, side along with recipient age, BMI and comorbidities. All graft kidneys were harvested laparoscopically.

resultsBoth the groups were comparable in terms of recipient age and BMI, donor age, creatinine, BMI, eGFR and comorbidities. Total ischemia time (P<0.001) and postoperative day (POD) 1 creatinine (P<0.001) was significantly more in RAKT. However, postoperative 1 month (P=0.12), 3 months (P=0.60) and 1 year (P=0.10) creatinine was comparable in both approaches. Postoperative complications (P=0.90) including hemoglobin drop (P=0.72) were comparable in both the groups. The days to half the creatinine from preoperative values was significantly less in OKT group (P=0.009). Serum Tacrolimus levels at day 3 (P=0.08) and day 7 (P=0.112) were also comparable in both the groups. Graft survival was 78.5% in OKT group and 82.14% in RAKT group with median follow-up of 60 months in both the groups.

conclusionIn this comprehensive propensity matched analysis of RAKT with OKT, we conclude that RAKT has similar outcomes as OKT at 1 year and 5 years follow-up. CIT, TIT, time to half creatinine and POD 1 creatinine values were higher in RAKT group, but eventually have comparable outcomes at further follow-up. Thus, RAKT, a novel approach is non-inferior to established OKT approach. However, further larger trials are required.