Clinical survey of current practice regarding treatment of children with borderline thyroid abnormalities.

aimRecently, there has been debate about reducing newborn screening (NBS) thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) cut-offs to identify children with mild, but potentially clinically significant, thyroid deficiency. Once identified by NBS, these children will be referred to paediatric endocrinologists for further testing and possible treatment; however, variation in current clinical practice is not known. The aim of this study is to survey Paediatric Endocrinologists in Australia and New Zealand to gain insight into clinical practice for the treatment of mild thyroid deficiency.

methodsA piloted questionnaire was sent to members of the Australasian Paediatric Endocrinologist Group. The survey asked the Australasian Paediatric Endocrinologist Group members about the investigations performed, treatment and follow-up for infants with different confirmatory serum TSH levels.

resultsThere were 42 completed surveys, a response rate of 34%. When presented with four case studies, 7% of clinicians would treat a child with confirmatory serum TSH of 8.7 mU/L with thyroxine, 69% would treat a child with confirmatory serum TSH 21.4 mU/L, 76% would treat a child with confirmatory serum TSH 24.3 mU/L and 95% would treat a child with confirmatory serum TSH 44.7 mU/L.

conclusionThis contemporary survey of clinicians regarding the treatment of mild thyroid deficiency in children has shown that clinical practice varies extensively. International and national guidelines on the treatment of congenital hypothyroidism should be updated to incorporate new evidence and ensure consistency across clinical practice.