On the relationship between inhibition and receptor occupancy by nondepolarizing neuromuscular blocking drugs.

backgroundNondepolarizing neuromuscular blocking drugs (NDNBs) are clinically used to produce muscle relaxation during general anesthesia. To better understand clinical properties of NDNBs, comparative in vitro pharmacologic studies have been performed. In these studies, a receptor binding model, which relies on the assumption that the inhibition, i.e., the effect of an NDNB, is proportional to the receptor occupancy by the drug, has been effectively used to describe obtained experimental data. However, it has not been studied in literature under which conditions the above assumption can be justified nor the assumption still holds in vivo. The purpose of this study is to explore the in vivo relationship between the inhibition and the receptor occupancy by an NDNB and to draw implications on how in vitro experimental results can be used to discuss the in vivo properties of NDNBs.

methodsAn ordinary differential equation model is employed to simulate physiologic processes of the activation of receptors by acetylcholine (ACh) as well as inhibition by an NDNB. With this model, the degree of inhibition is quantified by the fractional amount of receptors that are not activated by ACh due to the presence of an NDNB. The results are visualized by plotting the fractional amounts of the activated receptors as a function of the receptor occupancy.

resultsNumerical investigations reflecting in vivo conditions show that the degree of inhibition is not proportional to the receptor occupancy, i.e., there is a nonlinear relationship between the inhibition and the receptor occupancy. However, under a setting of high concentration of ACh reflecting a typical situation of in vitro experiments, the relationship between the inhibition and the receptor occupancy becomes linear, suggesting the validity of the receptor binding model. Also, it is found that the extent of nonlinearity depends on the selectivity of NDNBs for the two binding sites of the receptors.

conclusionsWhile the receptor binding model may be effective for estimating affinity of an NDNB through in vitro experiments, these models do not directly describe in vivo properties of NDNBs, because the nonlinearity between the inhibition and the receptor occupancy causes the modulation of the resultant concentration-effect relationships of NDNBs.