The Impact of Protein Type on Phosphorus Intake, Serum Phosphate Concentrations, and Nutrition Status in Adults with Chronic Kidney Disease: A Critical Review.

Lower phosphorus intake to prevent hyperphosphatemia for those with chronic kidney disease (CKD) is often recommended. Plant proteins are frequently restricted for their high phosphorus content despite having lower bioavailability. To summarize the evidence on protein type and dietary phosphorus intake, serum phosphate concentrations, and nutritional adequacy in adults with CKD, a search in MEDLINE via Ovid was conducted. Citation lists were reviewed to identify any additional articles. Sixteen articles were included-7 intervention (n = 290) and 9 observational (n = 4933). All intervention trials reported high-plant-protein diets provided adequate protein and adhered to low phosphorus diet guidelines. All intervention trials reported higher plant-protein intake was associated with lower serum phosphate; however, only 2 achieved statistical significance. For observational studies, 2 reported that higher proportions of plant to animal protein resulted in lower phosphorus intake but equivalent serum phosphate concentrations. Two reported that plant protein and animal protein had equivalent correlation values to phosphorus intake and no correlation to serum phosphate concentrations. One trial reported lower total phosphorus and protein intake among those who consumed more plant proteins but did not examine serum concentrations. Four reported lower serum phosphate concentrations among those who consumed more plant proteins but did not report dietary phosphorus intake. Of the observational studies that reported on protein intake, all reported lower protein intake among those with higher versus lower plant-protein intake. BMI tended to be lower among those consuming more plant protein. There was not a consistent relation between protein type and albumin concentrations. Routine restriction of plant-protein foods to prevent hyperphosphatemia in CKD would likely benefit from re-evaluation, as evidence does not suggest that higher plant-protein intake leads to higher serum phosphate concentrations or worse nutritional status, although longer-duration intervention trials with larger sample sizes appear to be warranted.