The utility of pediatric age-based weight estimation formulas for emergency drug dose calculations in obese children.

objectivesIn obese children, when drug therapy is required during emergency care, an estimation of ideal body weight is required for certain drug dose calculations. Some experts have previously speculated that age-based weight estimation formulas could be used to predict ideal body weight. The objectives of this study were to evaluate how accurately age-based formulas could predict ideal body weight and total body weight in obese children.

methodsThree age-based weight estimation formulas were evaluated in a secondary analysis, using a pooled sample of children from 3 academic emergency departments in South Africa. The estimates produced by the 3 formulas (and the PAWPER XL tape as a control) were compared against measured total body weight and ideal body weight. The percentages of estimates falling within 10% of the standard weight were used as the primary outcome measure (PW10).

resultsThis study included 1026 children. For ideal body weight estimations in obese children, the old Advanced Life Support formula, the new Advanced Life Support formula, and the Best Guess formula achieved PW10s (with 95% confidence intervals [CIs]) of 29% (27.2%, 30.8%), 41.4% (38.9%, 43.9%), and 48.3% (45.3%, 51.3%), respectively. For total body weight estimations, the formulas achieved PW10s of 3.6% (3.4%, 3.8%), 5.2% (4.9%, 5.5%), and 19.0% (17.8%, 20.2%). The PAWPER XL tape achieved an accuracy of ideal body weight estimation of 100% (93.9%, 100%) and total body weight estimation of 49.7% (46.7%, 52.7%) in obese children.

conclusionsThe age-based formulas were substantially less accurate at estimating total body weight and ideal body weight than existing length-based methods such as the PAWPER XL tape, and should not be used for this purpose.