Understanding Mechanisms of Change for Brief Alcohol Interventions Among Youth: Examination of Within-Session Interactions.

objectiveAlcohol brief interventions (BIs) for youth are efficacious, but effect sizes found have been modest. This article presents secondary data analyses from a randomized controlled trial of motivational interviewing-based (MI) alcohol BIs among youth in an emergency department, examining within-session predictors of alcohol outcomes at 3 months among those receiving BIs.

methodRisky drinkers (ages 14-20) received either a computer BI (n = 277) or therapist BI (n = 278). Within-session measures were obtained via computer metrics (therapist and computer BIs) and coding of audiotapes (therapist BI only). Parallel structural equation models examined direct and indirect effects of BI components on 3-month alcohol consumption and consequences, with posttest precursors of behavior change (e.g., importance, readiness, and intentions) as potential mediators. Components examined included reasons to avoid or reduce drinking, strengths, strategies for change, benefits of change, and leisure activities (computer BI only), and MI global ratings and MI-adherent behaviors (therapist BI only).

resultsFor both BIs, greater number of strategies directly predicted greater posttest scores, with posttest scores mediating the relationship between strategies and alcohol consumption at 3 months. Greater number of strengths directly predicted fewer alcohol-related consequences at 3 months for both BIs; however, strengths also indirectly predicted greater consumption, mediated by posttest scores. Greater number of reasons to avoid or reduce drinking directly predicted greater alcohol consumption for the therapist BI only.

conclusionsThese findings suggest ways to optimize the content and efficacy of alcohol BIs. Reviews of strategies such as refusal skills, protective behavioral strategies, and coping with negative affect may be particularly salient for reducing alcohol misuse.