A high level of mutation tolerance in the multifunctional sequence encoding the RNA encapsidation signal of an avian hepatitis B virus and slow evolution rate revealed by in vivo infection.

In all hepadnaviruses, protein-primed reverse transcription of the pregenomic RNA (pgRNA) is initiated by binding of the viral polymerase, P protein, to the ε RNA element. Universally, ε consists of a lower stem and an upper stem, separated by a bulge, and an apical loop. Complex formation triggers pgRNA encapsidation and the ε-templated synthesis of a DNA oligonucleotide (priming) that serves to generate minus-strand DNA. In vitro systems for duck hepatitis B virus (DHBV) yielded important insights into the priming mechanism, yet their relevance in infection is largely unexplored. Moreover, additional functions encoded in the DHBV ε (Dε) sequence could affect in vivo fitness. We therefore assessed the in vivo performances of five recombinant DHBVs bearing multiple mutations in the upper Dε stem. Three variants with only modestly reduced in vitro replication competence established chronic infection in ducks. From one variant but not another, three adapted new variants emerged upon passaging, as demonstrated by increased relative fitness in coinfections with wild-type DHBV. All three showed enhanced priming and replication competence in vitro, and in one, DHBV e antigen (DHBeAg) production was restored. Pronounced impacts on other Dε functions were not detected; however, gradual, synergistic contributions to overall performance are suggested by the fact of none of the variants reaching the in vivo fitness of wild-type virus. These data shed more light on the P-Dε interaction, define important criteria for the design of future in vivo evolution experiments, and suggest that the upper Dε stem sequences provided an evolutionary playground for DHBV to optimize in vivo fitness.